Rule 5 HOF voting
Friday, March 25th, 2005The way that the voters in the Baseball Hall of Fame perceive values is quite different than the way our country visualizes them. In baseball, what is the worst sin you could commit that would ban you from ever being inducted in Cooperstown? Lets examine the record of some of those that are in the HOF. First would be Ty Cobb, here are some of the crimes he committed. 1907: Slapped a black groundskeeper; when the man’s wife protested, he grabbed her by the neck. 1908: Assaulted a black laborer; shoved a black chambermaid down the stairs. 1909: Slapped a black elevator operator for being “insolent.” When a night watchman (also black) broke it up, Cobb slashed him several times with a knife. Fined $100. 1912: Pistol-whipped a would-be mugger to death; pummeled a crippled fan. 1914: Threatened a butcher with a gun and pistol-whipped his black assistant. It is safe to say that most of his crimes were rooted in bigotry, and were accepted by baseball, because baseball believed in bigotry. Besides he only committed one death, and that was way “in the past ” by the time Cooperstown opened in 1939. Then there is Cap Anson, the game’s first 3000 hit member. He also was known as the “Father of Apartheid in baseball.” It was because of his insistence that opposing teams, “get that nigger of the field,” that baseball banned blacks from the game for 60 years. On July 17, 1887 Anson spoke to the owners in NY, and on that day hence, a “gentlemen’s agreement” was made, and that white handshake stayed in place until 1947. Is that enough to keep Cap out of the Hall? Not to the 100% white voters back then.
Now the one sin that will keep you out of the HOF is posted in every clubhouse. “Betting on baseball is grounds for permanent banishment.” In football Paul Horning was suspended while he was a player for betting for an entire season, yet he was still allowed in the Football Hall of Fame. In baseball, it was the fear of betting that has caused Shoeless Joe Jackson to still be searching for his field of dreams, even though he batted .375 in that tainted World Series. In 1920 the courts acquitted Jackson and 7 others, but shortly after, the new Commissioner of baseball Judge Kennesaw Mountain Landis, said “Regardless of the verdict of juries, no player that throws a ball game, no player that entertains proposals or promises to throw a game, no player that sits in a conference with a bunch of crooked players and gamblers where the ways and means of throwing games are discussed, and does not promptly tell his club about it, will ever again play professional baseball.” In modern day lore Pete Rose was also guilty of the same sin and the last real Commissioner Bart Giamotti banned him for life because of his sins of gambling. Even though the courts put poor Pete in prison for taxes, that would not have kept him from the Hall, but his sin of betting did. That brings us to 2005. This conspiracy is a combination of JFK and Watergate. From Bud to Fehr, to McGwire, to Sammy, to Palmerio to Bonds. Each has committed a crime, perjury, but perjury is only a law of the land, not one of the rules of baseball. Last week in a vote of 165 voting members, Big Mac still got 65% of the vote. A lot more than Thurman Munson and Smoky Joe Wood combined. Mighty Mark could still be worthy of a bronze head in Cooperstown. Maybe everyone needs to look at the requirements for induction. There is one part that says something about “integrity of the game.” That clause should have more weight on getting in than a gambling slip. Each one of those “sluggers’ needs to look the sons of Roger Maris right in the eyes, and say they are sorry, but that will never happen, because as they would say. “What happened in the past, stays in the past.” It would also mean they each had some integrity, which done of them do. What this country needs is a real commissioner. Someone who really cares about the game. Someone who does things for the “good of the game.” Not someone who just wants to protect investments, but someone who wants to protect the integrity of the game. There is a another rule 5 in baseball. It is rule number 5, for the rules for election to the Baseball Hall of Fame that states: 5. Voting — Voting shall be based upon the player’s record, playing ability, integrity, sportsmanship, character, and contributions to the team(s) on which the player played. That rule should keep anyone that had steroid induced stats from gaining entrance. Then the next step is to ban all the records. Maybe this could be accomplished if the following sign could be placed in all clubhouses. “Anyone who cheats, lies, or defames the integrity of the game, will have all their records banned.”
The other rule that needs to be changed at the HOF is how to measure a player’s career. The number 1 reason for being elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame should be the number of times your team won the World Series, the second criteria should be the number of pennants your team won. If you took the career of Elston Howard, I would bet he is the only player in history to play on 10 pennant winning teams, and 4 World Champions, and not be in the Hall of Fame. Next would be Roger Maris, with 7 pennants and 3 rings. throw in a couple of MVP’s, and a 61* and you would think it would be considered a Hall of Fame career. Look at Thurman Munson he was an All-Star 7 times, played on 3 pennant winning teams, and 2 World Champions, in 11 seasons, yet he only received 2 votes from the Vets. Then there is my favorite Smoky Joe Wood. He was a winner of the Championship 4 times. He switched from pitching to playing for 6 more years. He tied Munson for last he the recent voting. It isn’t just longevity that makes you a HOF’er. It is winning. That is why you need to change the format and criteria for election.
The Fan’s Commish
Rick Swanson